Logo
Home
language
Loading...

Why Mining Is So Hard In Greenland

Dengar/Video/CNBC International/Why Mining Is So Hard In Greenland

Why Mining Is So Hard In Greenland

CNBC International
Pilih mode belajar:
3000 Oxford Words4000 IELTS Words5000 Oxford Words3000 Common Words1000 TOEIC Words5000 TOEFL Words

Subtitle (179)

0:01In 1799, Danish chemist Peter Abildgaard  formally identified cryolite – a white,  
0:07rare mineral from Greenland, dubbed as  “the ice that never melts”. Later used  
0:11in the production of aluminium,  a cryolite mine was set up on the  
0:14territory in the 1850s. That’s when a  lot started to change for the island. 
0:20Fast forward to 2026, and interest in  Greenland’s minerals has intensified.
0:25We need Greenland.
0:27We need Greenland for national protection.
0:29We need Greenland for national security.
0:31Now what I’m asking for is a piece of ice.
0:35Greenland is currently a self-governed  territory within the Kingdom of Denmark,  
0:39and it’s landed in the midst  of a geopolitical battle.
0:42We’re open for business but we are not for sale.
0:44We have to work together respectfully.
0:47No doubt, in Greenland if you want to exploit,  you, of course, have to respect our legislation.
0:53This is an Arctic island that's strategically  positioned. It's situated in an area that is  
0:59close to emerging shipping routes, and of course,  it's revered for its untapped mineral potential.
1:05There are a couple of very large  rare-earth projects that Donald  
1:08Trump is almost certainly interested  in. And I think the US is going to  
1:11be in charge of mineral rights or  highly influential in this area.
1:16The rare earth market, mineral market,  is a very small market. It's about  
1:19$10 billion dollars. It is, however,  servicing probably a $7 trillion market.
1:24So, why won't critical minerals  make Greenland rich? And what can?
1:38Greenland’s economy has long been  reliant on two major sectors: fishing,  
1:42which accounts for almost all of the island’s  exports - and public administration and services,  
1:47which cover health and education. You’ll notice  that mining is the smallest segment on the chart.
1:53However, Greenland’s biggest sector is  incredibly reliant on subsidies from Denmark.
1:58In 2024, Greenland received about  €553 million from Copenhagen,  
2:03representing about half of the territory's  expenditures – and around 20% of its GDP.
2:08But that’s not enough to support the entire  economy. In 2026, the National Bank of  
2:13Denmark expects a slowdown in Greenland’s growth,  citing major challenges in its public finances.
2:19When you look at Greenland's economy today, the  first thing to say is that it's very small. Its  
2:23nominal gross domestic product is somewhere  in the region of 3.3 billion US dollars. 
2:28It's also been growing at about 1% in recent  years, which is after some years of progress,  
2:33and it's slowing to that level. When you come to Greenland,  
2:36the kitchen table discussions is how to  combat inflation, the cost of living,  
2:41our health care system, all of the issues that  I think other countries also have top of mind.
2:47Greenland has been exploring ways  to become financially independent  
2:50from Denmark for a while – and  one industry could enable that.
2:53This is an island with the world's eighth  largest reserves of rare earth elements.  
2:57There are also significant deposits of  things like gold and cobalt and lithium,  
3:02and the list goes on from there. Some of the  mining companies described it as a mineral  
3:06Gold Rush, although analysts I've spoken  to are a bit more sceptical than that.  
3:10A study by the American Action  Forum estimates that the value of  
3:13Greenland’s known and realistically extractable  mineral resources could reach $186 billion.
3:19In an optimistic scenario, mines could bring  wealth to Greenland, like oil did for Norway,  
3:24through the creation of a sovereign  wealth fund. This could also ripple  
3:28through the local economy, by increasing  consumer demand and, in turn, more jobs.
3:32Every time there's some activity in the mineral  sector, they will charter the local boat,  
3:37the local shop, and so on. So right now,  the local communities are really feeling  
3:41the positive effect of that. It will take some  time before we fill it on a more national level.
3:45We've got more exploration than exploitation,  and in the exploration phase, there's a lot of  
3:51money to be made for local companies, because  the exploration companies are very small,  
3:56very few people, very few resources,  but they're usually well-funded,  
3:59and they buy all the services they need  locally. We don't mind if you find anything,  
4:04as long as you keep looking, because  that's where the money is for us right now.
4:08Since 1998, the Greenlandic government has  been delivering licenses to mining firms for  
4:13the prospecting, exploration and exploitation  of mineral resources - and it’s been busy.
4:19Greenland’s trove of minerals extends  well beyond cryolite, and includes gold,  
4:24gemstones and industrial rocks. And with  36.1 million tonnes of rare earth elements,  
4:30the territory boasts some of the world’s  biggest reserves. It’s also home to two  
4:35of the world’s largest deposits, a natural  accumulation of minerals in the Earth’s crust.
4:41Between 2003 and 2026, the Greenlandic  government granted 138 licenses, mainly  
4:47to British, Canadian and Australian firms,  but only two mines are actively operating:  
4:53Nalunaq gold mine and White  Mountain anorthosite mine.
4:57The largest licence holder, Amaroq, has  been present on the island since 2017,  
5:02and is exploring and exploiting gold, copper,  germanium and gallium, amongst others.
5:08It was all the way back to 2012, I noticed  how much interest it was in Greenland,  
5:13especially from China. The question was  like, how are you going to do it? Is it  
5:17feasible to do it? And I thought, with the kind  of Icelandic know-how, an Icelandic background,  
5:22if you could marry up assets, operation  and capital, then it could be done.
5:26We started with a gold mine, one of the  highest-grade gold mines in the world,  
5:29which means it should yield high  and good free cash flow. And it is,  
5:33in our view, easiest to start with  gold, because gold is easily movable.
5:38The intention was to utilize the  cash flow from those operations  
5:41to find large deposits that are  sitting on the surface there.
5:45New critical mineral discoveries  and growing geopolitical demand  
5:48have sparked renewed interest for  investments in mining companies.
5:52The investment picture for Greenland's  mining is still one that is developing.  
5:56It's still very early stages. The E.U. is  looking to form a strategic partnership  
6:00with Greenland to look at improving  its raw material supply chains. And  
6:04one notable investment that stands  out is for a company called Critical  
6:08Metals. They have a project called  Tanbreez, which is a rare earths mine.
6:12In October 2025, Critical Metals  received a letter of interest from the  
6:16U.S. Export-Import bank for a loan worth  up to $120 million to develop Tanbreez.
6:22And while no rare earths are  being mined in Greenland yet,  
6:25large investments in the sector  are being eyed by the wealthiest.
6:29Since 2019, Jeff Bezos, Bill Gates and Michael  Bloomberg all invested in Kobold Metals,  
6:34a mineral exploration company that uses  AI and machine learning. Altman joined  
6:39them as an investor in 2022. However,  in 2025, KoBold ceased its exploration  
6:45work on the island and returned its stake  in the project to its partner, 80 Mile.
6:50The company, formerly known as BlueJay Mining, is  being advised by broker and analyst firm SP Angel.
6:56The recent dramatic rise in gold  prices, silver prices, copper,  
7:01tin, a whole range of other commodities is  definitely bringing new investors back into  
7:06the mining sector. And Greenland is a very  interesting place to look for new minerals.
7:13If you want to invest in Greenlandic minerals or  energy potentials, it is very capital intensive.  
7:19And in order for that to succeed, investors need  stability. You need to engage in the first part  
7:25of the value chain. We only got the minerals.  We don't have the down-the-line production.
7:31There are no roads going across Greenland.  You either have to get somewhere by plane,  
7:36by helicopter, by boat. You have to  build everything from scratch. You've  
7:40got to do your own water. You've  got to create your own power.  
7:43You need your own communications. So  your project has to be really worth it.
7:46You need to do everything on your own. We started with a project that has costed  
7:50us in total about $200 million from the start to  finish. Now I want to say two thirds of that cost  
7:57was the processing plant to build the house, put  the plant in, and about 50 to 60% of that cost was  
8:04people. 1/3 was to set up the roads, the bridges,  the harbor, and get the mining going and so on.
8:10It is a chicken and egg situation. The mines  can't get going until the processing is there,  
8:15and the processors won't put  the money in until the mines  
8:18are going. So this is where government  needs to step in and help the chain.
8:23If investment and infrastructure already  make Greenland a risky bet for mining,  
8:27then additional constraints—such as  insurance challenges and the impacts  
8:31of climate change could really slow things down.
8:34Our society is struck by climate changes,  by changes in the infrastructure. We have  
8:40power outings. We have the distribution and  the supplies being cut off once in a while,  
8:45and the companies need to deal with that.
8:47Scientists are deeply alarmed with the scale and  pace of the thawing of Greenland ice sheet. These  
8:54environmental considerations are critically  important to Greenland's economy. You only  
8:58have to look at fishing, which is just undeniably  essential to Greenland's economic success. But it  
9:04is also true that climate change, inadvertently,  is creating conditions in which it might actually  
9:09be easier to access some of these raw materials.  But building kind of floating docks rather than  
9:15investing in infrastructure for a port, for  example, is something that is happening more.
9:20It's not that easy to find rare earths. And  then finding those rare earths where there's  
9:23a reasonable grade and where the metallurgy  means you can easily extract the rare earths  
9:28is even more difficult. So what you really  want to do is produce a concentrate of some  
9:32sort and ship that probably to a place where  they can more easily extract the rare earths  
9:38but it’s all about economics. The Chinese are  processing rare earths very cost effectively,  
9:43really quite cheaply. And the Chinese  haven't been that bothered about putting  
9:46acid into their environment and they’ll  have to clean that up one of these days.  
9:50Greenland can't afford that. They  need to get it right first time.
9:54There has been local opposition to these  projects in Greenland in the past. And we  
9:58can see that by example of the banning of  high-level uranium mining on the territory.
10:03In 2021, the Kvanefjeld site – which holds both  critical minerals and uranium – was shut down  
10:09following the arrival of a new government, which  banned the extraction of the chemical element.  
10:13The mining company Energy Transition  Minerals, which had planned to extract  
10:17the highly toxic and radioactive metal,  is now suing Greenland’s government for  
10:22compensation of up to $11.5bn on the grounds of  expropriation, the government seizure of property.
10:29It's a huge deposit. It's got great rare earth  grades, quite a lot of uranium and thorium in it,  
10:35and the Greenlanders really don't  want any radionuclides. They really  
10:39don't want any risk of poisoning the  fish docks or the land in that area.
10:45Another issue faced by investors and  mining companies is finding skilled  
10:49workers. As investment increases, so does  the necessity for a trained labor force.
10:53Currently, we have about 40 or 50% of our  employees are Greenlandic. When you will have  
10:58a lot of mines in Greenland, that will get smaller  and smaller, because there's only 50,000 people,  
11:04and only a portion of that can work. You then  need to find people that are willing to work  
11:08on maybe four weeks on shift or four weeks  off. And we have developed a plan to do that,  
11:13mostly through people from places  like Poland, Serbia, Kazakhstan.
11:18We are still very much dependent on a  foreign workforce, and about 12 to 13%  
11:23of the workforce here are foreigners.  It's a sign of an economy in growth.
11:27When you are a small economy and a small  workforce, you have to import a lot of  
11:32workforce from the outside to develop these  sectors. So we are not interested in opening 10  
11:37mines. It would mean that we would be outnumbered  in our own country and we cannot accommodate that.
11:42While it's still quite a nascent industry,  there are other projects in development,  
11:47and yet there does seem to be  a cap on that ambition as well.
11:50The shortage of skilled workers directly  stems from a declining and ageing population.
11:56In early 2026, Greenland’s population stood at  just over 55,500 inhabitants. But government data  
12:03projections show a steep decline over the next 20  years, with the territory expected to lose around  
12:0920% of its people by 2050. High mortality  and emigration are contributing factors.
12:15And like in many parts of the world,  
12:17Greenland is experiencing falling birth  rates. And the territory is also known  
12:21for having the highest levels of abortion in  the world – due to socio-economic conditions.
12:26It's a vast Arctic Island. That trend of bringing  
12:28in foreign workers is only  likely to continue from here.
12:32While the Greenlandic government operates a  corporate tax of 25% on foreign companies,  
12:37and mining licenses include a 5% royalty  on uranium and rare earth elements,  
12:43profits are still split between Denmark  and Greenland. And if mining profits exceed  
12:47DKK75 million per year, Denmark will  reduce its grant by 50% of the excess.
12:54So, what could help Greenland  make its population rich?
12:57While waiting for the ice to melt – and future  mining projects to take shape – Greenland has  
13:02turned to other sources of income such as tourism  and the potential of exporting its freshwater,  
13:07which could be used as drinking water, for  food production or in industrial settings.
13:11Tourism is a big focus for Greenland  for diversifying its economy,  
13:15it harbors ambitions of 40% of its export  value coming from the tourism sector by 2035.
13:21We're trying to sell, first of all,  surplus energy produced in Greenland,  
13:25either for exports or for arms projects  like data centers, because, you know, a  
13:30data center basically just requires a good  connectivity, lots of land, a building,  
13:35and a cooling mechanism. And definitely here  the cooling mechanism is: we open the door.
13:40Greenland's mineral potential is enormous,  but so are the barriers to turning these  
13:45projects into a success. Overcoming those  barriers is going to take a lot of private  
13:49and probably state capital. The question  for Greenlanders, I'm sure, is whether it  
13:53becoming a success story and it developing these  riches will actually get seen by its population.