Analysis of Labor's control

The topic is the Australian Labor Party (ALP)

The event happened on Monday, 27 July 2026, at 4:50 am

Labor's discipline under Anthony Albanese was shown at the 50th ALP national convention

Journalists were unhappy because there were no big debates at the conference

In the past, the ALP had big debates on issues like same-sex marriage, which helped the party

The media wanted a big debate to report on, but Labor's issue is what it loses with its control

Labor's discipline under Albanese is well-known, and he has control over different parts of the party

Some debates were settled behind closed doors, and the only problem for the PM was an escalator

Former minister Ed Husic said Labor's caucus was not allowed to disagree with the government's views

Husic spoke about this on Afternoon Briefing, saying Labor was 'allergic' to disagreement

Husic tried to change the party's platform on Israel, but it failed after the Maritime Union withdrew support

Husic was surprised by the effort to stop his proposal, and he said Labor was gagged

Senior Labor figures disagreed with Husic, saying he didn't have enough support

The party adopted a position supported by Victorian MPs, which was consistent with the government's view

Husic warned that a party without democracy loses touch with voters

A broader point is at play here

The conference is not a public forum, but a meeting of Labor members and politicians

Albanese is not the only leader with a strong grip on the party

Bob Hawke had a strong conference in 1990, but he allowed opponents to speak

Hawke won the debate, but members had a chance to argue

Albanese risks sending a message that the party floor is not for real debates

This goes back to Husic's point about Labor not allowing disagreement

One Nation is popular because it listens to voters who feel ignored by major parties

But One Nation's internal mechanisms are not democratic, it's Pauline Hanson's way

Voters like One Nation because Hanson is different from mainstream politicians

The risk for Albanese is that his control of the conference affects how voters see him

Imagine a conference with big debates, and how that would be used against the government

Albanese wants to avoid giving his opponents ammunition on culture wars

Labor figures think voters care about the party's unity, not its internal debates

The Liberals have an electoral problem because of their lack of discipline

Debating immigration is okay, but flirting with multiculturalism failing is risky

Labor is cosplaying unity to contrast with the Liberal Party

Labor powerbroker Don Farrell said the display of unity was deliberate

The strategy is to paint the opposition as divided, so Labor needs to show unity

The ABC's politics podcast dives into big stories, giving a balanced look

Albanese's strategy has worked so far, he has won two elections

He will welcome coverage of the conference being dull and stage-managed

The PM said Labor is more cohesive and united than ever before

Hawke gave members the microphone, but Albanese's control risks looking like taking the win without debate

Patricia Karvelas is the host of ABC News Afternoon Briefing

See more ABC coverage

Pratique d'écoute