Western Australia's GST Deal Might Change
The topic of tax is being discussed.
Fire alarms went off after Western Australian government officials criticized the GST review authors.
Alarm bells rang in government offices after the criticism.
Treasurer Rita Saffioti joked about losing GST money before a press conference was interrupted.
It was not entirely a joke.
People had to leave the media conference due to a fire alarm.
Western Australia's economy has benefited from a special GST deal, receiving an extra $22 billion.
The extra money helped Western Australia have record surpluses.
A report said Western Australia got 113% of its fiscal needs from GST, while other states got 98%.
Western Australia's leaders believe the money was paid back through company tax.
The Productivity Commission agreed with other states that the deal created unfair outcomes.
Premier Roger Cook strongly disagreed with the report's conclusions.
Western Australia could lose $6 billion if the deal ends, which is not being suggested.
Roger Cook says Western Australia's resources sector is vital to the country's economy.
The amount of money lost depends on the commission's final recommendations.
Western Australia is focusing on convincing the prime minister and treasurer, rather than other states.
The next steps will be decided by politics.
Politics caused the problem, and it will likely decide what happens next.
The 2018 deal was made to resolve a political issue for the Western Australian government.
The deal was made between Mark McGowan and Scott Morrison in 2018.
A falling iron ore price reduced royalties and GST payments for Western Australia.
Roger Cook criticized those he called 'east-coast clowns' for proposing a GST change.
The GST was meant to make states equal by giving more money to those with lower earnings or higher expenses.
Western Australia's share was falling due to lower royalties and a strong economy.
A chart shows what happened to royalties and GST payments in recent years.
The current debate is about whether Western Australia should get extra money and how it should get it.
Economist Saul Eslake believes Western Australia does not need extra money.
He thinks Western Australia is not holding up the national economy.
Saul Eslake said Western Australia benefits from exports, largely due to China's demand.
The state argues that it needs support to benefit from China's demand for iron ore.
Aaron Morey said running Western Australia's economy takes a lot of resources.
The Productivity Commission thinks the mining sector is easy to manage, but Aaron Morey disagrees.
He said it is not easy to run a world-class mining sector.
The question is how this issue can be resolved.
The Productivity Commission is not against Western Australia getting extra money.
The commission's concern is that the GST is not meant to fund specific projects or priorities.
Iron ore royalties and GST payments are increasing for Western Australia.
The current system funds Western Australia to 113% of its needs.
The commission said any change to the system needs to be justified and beneficial.
Eslake and others do not think the case for change has been made.
The commission suggests adjusting the GST formula or providing funding another way.
The latter option leaves funds open to change by the federal government.
The former option is too complex, according to the Western Australian treasurer.
Rita Saffioti said trying to change the deal would disadvantage Western Australia.
The 2018 deal is enshrined in legislation, making it hard to change.
Two federal Liberals said they would not agree to change the deal.
The prime minister told Roger Cook that the current arrangements would remain.
Basil Zempilas does not trust the prime minister to keep his promise.
He mentioned the prime minister's previous broken promises.
The decision is now up to the prime minister.
One way to see this is that the prime minister might not want to start another fight.
The other way is that the prime minister might think twice about opening up another fight.
Especially since it could risk losing Western Australian seats in the next election.
It is possible the Commonwealth could find a way to change the deal without hurting Western Australia.
If all else fails, Western Australia has the option to secede.
Anthony Albanese once wrote 'No Change To WA GST' on a journalist's arm.
A journalist asked if secession is tempting.
Roger Cook said every Western Australian premier thinks about secession at times.
But he said it is not an option and they do not want to be separate from the rest of Australia.
Western Australia just wants to be rewarded for its economic contributions.
More stories from Western Australia are available.
Topic: Agricultural Pest Control
Topic: Agricultural Pest Control
Topic: Feel Good
Topic: History
Topic: Real Estate Industry
See more ABC coverage in your search results
Promotion
Top Stories
Topic: Earthquakes
Topic: War
Topic: World Politics
Topic: Aged Care
Related stories
Topic: Federal Government
Analysis by Annabel Crabb
Topic: State and Territory Government
Related topics
Albany
Broome
Bunbury
Economy
Federal - State Issues
Geraldton
Kalgoorlie
Karratha
Perth
State and Territory Government
Tax
Top Stories
Topic: Earthquakes
Topic: War
Topic: World Politics
Topic: Aged Care
Topic: World Politics
Just In
LIVE
Topic: Food and Drink
Topic: Crime
Topic: Feel Good